Thursday, November 27, 2025
Tuesday, April 8, 2025
Vilde Frang, Vladimir Jurowski and the London Philharmonic Orchestra play Beethoven and Schumann in ADDA Alicante
A few years ago, a concert program comprising two
works by Beethoven, and one by Schuman would not, for me, have aroused much
interest. That is the value of an abono, a subscription, because a subscription
means that you have opted for an entire season of performances and thus one
goes to whatever is on offer. My wife and I have had a subscription to Alicante’s
ADDA auditorium for several years and so we are now used to attending concerts
that would not usually be in our comfort zone, which is that of twentieth and twenty-first
century music. Last night in ADDA, we received a clear statement of what we have
been missing over the years when we repeatedly tried to edit out what we didn’t “like”.
The concert was by the London Philharmonic Orchestra
under Vladimir Jurowski and featured the violin playing of Vilde Frang. Right,
that has got the star billing out of the way! The concert presented Beethoven’s Coriolan Overture, Robert Schumann’s Violin Concerto,
and then Beethoven’s Symphony No. 5. For
someone who does not normally warm to Beethoven’s
symphonies, I confess that in concert over the last two months I have heard
numbers four, five and seven, and all three in their own way, have proved to be
the highlights of a very rich musical year. My fear of cliché often gets in the
way, but these three performances, and last night’s number five included, have
all been outstanding.
Vladimir Jurowski needs no introduction. He is a
justifiably a world-famous conductor. He is very economical, highly proficient
and a very precise conductor. There are no grand or grandiose gestures, just
content. The way he communicated what he wanted to stress in this performance
of Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony was both subtle and dramatically perfect. His
indication of the syncopations in the final movement, for instance, were both
precise and perfectly judged. In the central movements, Beethoven’s
memory of wind bands in the street were clear, but the context was always
architectural, with nothing being played for momentary effect. The pace of the
first movement was fast and this “knock of fate on the door” was truly
frightening. Again, I am tempted to describe the playing and the conducting as
perfect.
The Coriolan Overture in its own way a masterpiece.
Here Beethoven is trying to give us a complete Shakespeare play in five
minutes. The ending, where treason results in public disgrace, is telling.
The Violin Concerto of Robert Schumann is potentially
at least a problematic work. It is a late work, perhaps conceived when Robert
Schumann was not fully in control of his own mind. But how many of us care when
the result is what we heard? Vilde Frang’s playing
made sense of this rather rambling score and the orchestral accompaniment was
always sympathetic to her substantial dynamic. The sound from her Guarneri was
something to behold. She did play an encore, which I believe was Montanari’s Giga
Senza Basso.
I intend to repeat the subscription for another year at least!
Sunday, April 28, 2024
The Philharmonia with Suzuki and Queyras in Schumann and Dvorak - another case of "no superlatives"
Some time ago, for a review of the concert in Alicante’s ADDA auditorium, I used the headline “No superlatives”. I chose the words not because I wanted to question the quality of the experience, but quite the opposite. The concept of “superlative” was itself transcended by the quality of the music and performance in that concert. Indeed, a superlative only makes sense when a comparison is to be made. But to what can we compare perfection? Last night the ADDA audience experienced another “No superlatives” concert. Perhaps I am reverting to my north of England Yorkshire stereotype where the judgment “I couldn't fault it” represents the highest possible praise.
The concert in question was delivered by superstars. Jean-Guihen Queyras was the cello soloist and Masaaki Suzuki conducted the Philharmonia Orchestra. I lived in London for twenty years and the Philharmonia, known then paradoxically those years ago as the New Philharmonia, was always my personal orchestra of choice whenever I scanned the monthly South Bank agenda. Last night, the richness and dynamics of the orchestral sound were stunning, as was the orchestra’s control of rhythm and phrasing, so important in the evening’s principal work, Dvorak’s Eighth Symphony.
If the orchestra noticeably excelled, then Masaaki Suzuki was surprisingly anonymous. There can be no greater compliment to a conductor to admit that you really did not notice him or her. Masaaki Suzuki appeared to let the music flow naturally, seamlessly, to such an extent that at times he seemed superfluous. We might all aspire to such transparency, but achieving it demands true artistry, true and supreme ability. When, to accompany an encore, Masaaki Suzuki return to the platform to conduct a lyrical Slavonic Dance by Dvorak carrying a triangle, which he threatened to play. Only then did the attention focus on him and him alone. He used the instrument almost as a tease, still allowing the dulcet tones of Dvorak’s melody to shine.
In the first half we had heard Jean-Guihen Queyras play the Robert Schumann Cello Concerto. Specifically here, superlatives do not apply. Neither can the label “virtuoso” be attached to the performance, whose quality was way beyond such words. The three movements are played without a break and the composer’s imagination was clearly running wild at the time. Personally, I often find Schumann’s music rather impenetrable, but not in this performance.
As an encore Jean-Guihen Queyras played the Sarabande
from Bach’s Cello Suite No. 4, preceded by a short Ukrainian melody. The music
had a life of its own thanks to these amazing performances. Again, no
superlatives.

